Part of the data ring
FightIndex
Heavyweight Boxing

Ernie Schaaf vs Primo Carnera

A fight that actually happened — and everything both records say about it.

Ernie Schaaf and Primo Carnera met once (1933). Primo Carnera won in 1933 by ko.

Side by side

Ernie SchaafPrimo Carnera
Reach85″ (215.9 cm)
Height77″ (195.6 cm)
Reach advantage+10.38%
58–14Record88–14
40%Finish rate81%
14Longest unbeaten run25
61Recorded bouts99
OrthodoxStanceOrthodox

A comparison of what is on record. Nothing here predicts a result.

Common opponents

Both fought these 5. This is the comparison the siloed databases cannot make, because it needs every fight list linked to every other.

OpponentErnie SchaafPrimo Carnera
Max Baer W L
Tommy Loughran L W
Paulino Uzcudun W W
Paulino Uzcudun W W
Young Stribling W L

Careers side by side

Ernie Schaaf

1930 win vs Murray Gitlitz (1927)win vs Yale Okun (1927)win vs Ray Neuman (1927)draw vs Benny Touchstone (1927)win vs Dan Lieber (1927)win vs Al Friedman (1927)win vs Sergeant Jack Adams (1927)win vs Jack Gagnon (1927)win vs Ad Stone (1927)win vs Jack Darnell (1927)win vs Johnny Risko (1928)win vs Bud Gorman (1928)win vs James Jay Lawless (1928)loss vs Tiger Jack Payne (1928)win vs Big Boy Peterson (1928)win vs Harold Mays (1928)win vs Pat McCarthy (1928)win vs Benny Touchstone (1928)win vs Emilio Solomon (1928)win vs Yale Okun (1928)loss vs Johnny Risko (1929)loss vs Meyer K.O. Christner (1929)win vs Jack Renault (1929)win vs Jack Gagnon (1929)win vs Murray Gitlitz (1929)loss vs Tommy Loughran (1929)win vs Al Friedman (1929)loss vs Young Con O'Kelly (1929)win vs Max Baer (1930)loss vs Babe Hunt (1930)win vs Tommy Loughran (1930)draw vs Paul Pantaleo (1930)win vs Meyer K.O. Christner (1930)win vs Al Friedman (1930)win vs Giacomo Bergomas (1931)win vs Frankie Simms (1931)win vs Jack Dorval (1931)win vs Tuffy Griffiths (1931)win vs Roberto Roberti (1931)win vs Victorio Campolo (1931)win vs Angus Snyder (1931)win vs Jim Maloney (1931)win vs Leo Williams (1931)win vs Jack Gagnon (1931)win vs Paul Pantaleo (1931)loss vs Tommy Loughran (1931)win vs Dynamite Jackson (1931)win vs Dick Daniels (1931)win vs James J. Braddock (1931)win vs Edward "Unknown" Winston (1932)loss vs Max Baer (1932)win vs Ted Sandwina (1932)win vs Paulino Uzcudun (1932)win vs Salvatore Ruggirello (1932)loss vs Stanley Poreda (1932)win vs Tony Galento (1932)win vs Jack Gross (1932)win vs Young Stribling (1932)loss vs Primo Carnera (1933)win vs Stanley Poreda (1933)
winlossdraw / NC1927–1933

Primo Carnera

1930 1940 win vs Constant Barrick (1928)win vs Epifanio Islas (1928)win vs Salvatore Ruggirello (1928)win vs Joe Thomas (1928)win vs Leon Sebilo (1928)win vs Franz Diener (1929)loss vs Young Stribling (1929)win vs Jack Stanley (1929)win vs Hermann Jaspers (1929)win vs Feodor Nikolaeff (1929)win vs Joe Thomas (1929)win vs Jose Lete (1929)win vs Jack Humbeeck (1929)win vs Marcel Nilles (1929)win vs Moise Bouquillon (1929)win vs Ernst Roesemann (1929)win vs Reggie Meen (1930)win vs Paulino Uzcudun (1930)loss vs Jim Maloney (1930)win vs Jack Gross (1930)win vs Pat McCarthy (1930)win vs Riccardo Bertazzolo (1930)win vs George Cook (1930)win vs Bearcat Wright (1930)win vs George Godfrey (1930)win vs KO Christner (1930)win vs Sam Baker (1930)win vs Leon Chevalier (1930)win vs Neil Clisby (1930)win vs Jack McAuliffe II (1930)win vs George Trafton (1930)win vs Frank Zaveta (1930)win vs Chuck Wiggins (1930)win vs Sully Montgomery (1930)win vs Roy Clark (1930)win vs Farmer Lodge (1930)win vs Johnny Erickson (1930)win vs Jim Sigman (1930)win vs Buster Martin (1930)win vs Cowboy Billy Owens (1930)win vs Elzear Rioux (1930)win vs Big Boy Peterson (1930)win vs Victorio Campolo (1931)win vs King Levinsky (1931)loss vs Jack Sharkey (1931)win vs Armando De Carolis (1931)win vs Roberto Roberti (1931)win vs Knute Hansen (1931)win vs Bud Gorman (1931)win vs Umberto Torriani (1931)win vs Pat Redmond (1931)win vs Jim Maloney (1931)win vs Young Spence (1932)win vs James Merriott (1932)win vs Joe Rice (1932)win vs KO Christner (1932)win vs Big Boy Peterson (1932)win vs King Levinsky (1932)win vs John Schwake (1932)win vs José Santa (1932)win vs Les Kennedy (1932)win vs Jack Taylor (1932)win vs Gene Stanton (1932)win vs Ted Sandwina (1932)win vs Art Lasky (1932)win vs Jack Gagnon (1932)loss vs Stanley Poreda (1932)win vs Hans Birkie (1932)win vs Jerry Pavelec (1932)win vs Jack Gross (1932)loss vs Larry Gains (1932)win vs Hans Schönrath (1932)win vs Maurice Griselle (1932)win vs Don McCorkindale (1932)win vs George Cook (1932)win vs Pierre Charles (1932)win vs Ernst Gühring (1932)win vs Moise Bouquillon (1932)win vs Paulino Uzcudun (1933)win vs Jack Sharkey (1933)win vs Ernie Schaaf (1933)win vs Victorio Campolo (1934)loss vs Max Baer (1934)win vs Tommy Loughran (1934)win vs Big Boy Brackey (1935)win vs Ford Smith (1935)win vs Walter Neusel (1935)loss vs Joe Louis (1935)win vs Ray Impelletiere (1935)win vs Erwin Klausner (1935)win vs Seal Harris (1935)loss vs Leroy Haynes (1936)win vs Isidoro Gastanaga (1936)win vs Josip Zupan (1937)loss vs Albert Di Meglio (1937)loss vs Luigi Musina (1945)win vs Sam Gardner (1945)win vs Michel Blevens (1945)loss vs Luigi Musina (1946)
winlossdraw / NC1928–1946

See what every site in this family answers

Published by

Amit Sharma

Auckland real-estate agent and marketer. Builds free, sourced data tools.